The best Goodreads alternatives in 2026
An honest look at five reading trackers — what they do well, where they fall short, and which one fits how you read.
Quick comparison
| Goodreads | StoryGraph | LibraryThing | Bookly | My Book Vault | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Price | Free | Free / Plus $5/mo | Free / $25/yr | $5/mo | Free / Plus $3.99/mo |
| Platform | Web + mobile app | Web + mobile app | Web | Mobile only | Web (any device) |
| Social features | Heavy | Moderate | Light | None | None |
| Stats dashboard | Basic | Advanced | Basic | Reading timer | Detailed |
| ISBN auto-fill | Yes | Yes | Yes | Manual | Yes (Open Library) |
| Privacy | Amazon-owned | Independent | Independent | Independent | Independent |
| CSV import | No | Yes | Yes | No | Yes (Plus) |
A closer look
Goodreads
Best for: Readers who want a massive community and author interactions
Strengths
- Largest book database with deep catalog coverage
- Author Q&As and reading challenges with millions of participants
- Massive community for reviews, recommendations, and book clubs
Drawbacks
- Owned by Amazon — your reading data feeds their ad ecosystem
- Cluttered UI that hasn't been meaningfully updated in years
- Slow to load, and the social feed dominates the experience
StoryGraph
Best for: Readers who want mood/pace data and AI-powered recommendations
Strengths
- Modern design with mood and pace tracking for each book
- Content warnings and AI-powered recommendations
- Easy import from Goodreads to migrate your library
Drawbacks
- Can feel complex if you just want a simple tracker
- Social features are still prominent throughout the app
- Some features locked behind a paywall
LibraryThing
Best for: Serious catalogers who want deep metadata control
Strengths
- Rich cataloging with detailed metadata fields
- Active community of librarian-types and collectors
- ISBN scanning and strong database coverage
Drawbacks
- Dated interface that can feel overwhelming
- Steep learning curve for new users
- Less focused on reading progress tracking
Bookly
Best for: Mobile readers who want a reading timer
Strengths
- Beautiful mobile design with intuitive reading timer
- Page-by-page tracking with daily reading goals
- Clean, distraction-free mobile experience
Drawbacks
- Mobile only — no web access from a computer
- Subscription required for basic features
- No CSV export — your data is locked in
My Book Vault
Best for: Readers who want to track books and stats without the social noise
Strengths
- Clean and fast — no social feeds, no algorithms, no ads
- ISBN auto-fill from Open Library with cover art, page count, and more
- Detailed stats dashboard with monthly pace, genre breakdown, and ratings
- Privacy-first — you own your data, always
- Works on any device — mobile or desktop, no app install needed
- CSV export and import so you're never locked in
- Free tier with 10 books, 14-day full-access trial with no credit card
Drawbacks
- Newer platform — smaller community
- No reading timer feature
- No built-in social community or book clubs
Why we built My Book Vault
We built My Book Vault because we wanted a reading tracker that stayed out of the way. Every app we tried wanted us to follow people, rate things for an algorithm, or scroll a feed we never asked for.
So we made the opposite. No social feed. No recommendations. No algorithms deciding what you see. Just add your books, track what you're reading, and see your stats.
Your data is yours. Export it anytime. Import it from wherever. We're not building a social network — we're building the reading tracker we wished existed.
Ready to try something simpler?
Free for up to 10 books. Full access for 14 days. No credit card required.
Start Your Free Trial